Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts

War memories

Odd as it seems, this post is directly related to the previous one...though how I got HERE from THERE is something I shall leave to your imagination.

Since I moved to the apartment, I pretty regularly have the idiot box/boob tube/brain degenerative device or whatever you want to call the tv going quite often when not listening to Pandora.

Not that I don't love Pandora...but they cannot get it through their electronic skull that loving Gold City =/= loving the Gaither Trio...

Anyhow, I found a "new" station playing the A-Team, so I set it up to DVR and have watched/listened to several episodes.

For both people on the planet not familiar with the A-Team, the premise was simple; wrongly accused commando unit from the Vietnam War was on the run from the government helping every day citizens whom the government was unwilling or impotent to help.

Some of the paradigms surrounding the show are very interesting. Government officials are generally dishonest/untrustworthy, including government officials, cops of various branches, and the army.

The A-Team would be despised except their actions kept showing the revulsion America in the early 80s felt for anyone having to do with Vietnam was overcome by A) the good deeds the A-Team performed for the people in that episode and B) Murdock.

Howling Mad Murdock was driven insane, presumably by the horrors he saw and experienced in Vietnam. Yet he was portrayed as funny, charming, deeply caring, sympathetic and empathetic.

The show of course reflected much of the public thought of the time. Anyone who had taken part in the war was looked on with suspicion at best and outright hostility or worse at other times. Our soldiers had failed us in two ways.

First, they had taken part in a war that had come to be identified as being part of Imperialism in general and American expansionism in particular.

Second, and arguably more important in the degeneration of respect for them, they failed to win. America loves a winner and has no time for a loser...even if that loser is them self.

It did not help that many...not all, but a significant and noticeable percentage...of the soldiers in that war were under-educated young men unprepared either to research the right and wrong of the war...or their actions in it...or for the American social response to their participation in what became a deeply unpopular war.


So when anything relating to the Vietnam War was portrayed in books, movies, radio, news, or television, the slant was almost universally negative. Had the A-Team been war heroes instead of "wrongfully convicted" men fighting against the government, which was identified in the American mind with the government that had leftover cachet of being involved in the War, it is probable the show would have been rejected.

The only way to portray Vietnam vets in a positive light therefore was as rebels against either the War itself in some way, portraying soldiers becoming inhuman through their experiences (Platoon, Full metal Jacket), or the country having portrayed their men by a corrupt government knowingly leaving behind prisoners of war (Rambo, First Blood).

Positive portrayals were unknown and unmake able for decades.

This has changed as reexaminations of things have taken place. To be sure, heroes are still hard to portray in Vietnam, but various means have been attempted (We Were Soldiers, Rescue Dawn) with varying success.

Okay, so all of this does not exactly break new ground.

But what if the A-Team were re-made today? This time they would, of course, be falsely convicted of a crime they...did/did not commit in Afghanistan/Iraq/Cuba/Venezuela.

How would they be portrayed? Enemies of the government? Stooges? Victims? Pawns? Heroes for supporting the government or heroes for opposing it?

Would public officials be almost universally portrayed in a positive light...or as villains?

Instead of Hannibal Smith, master-planner paragon of virtue who kept his men alive and patriotic through an unpopular war, we would have what?

Instead of scheming, con-artist ladies man Templeton Peck we would have....what?

Instead of a war-torn mind keeping a tenuous group on reality through association with his friends and "war buddy family", how would Murdock be portrayed?

And what about over-strong, weak-minded gold wearing follower B.A? Go back and watch the show...you will see what I mean. A good-hearted man always protecting the weak and willing to do so for no money...but incapable of thought outside, "What's the plan, Hannibal?"

And what of guys like Decker, the good/bad General Stockwell, etc.?

In other words, how does society at large perceive the soldiers in the Middle East, the government that sent and keeps them there, and the returnees from the war?

What would a show that accurately captured the mood of the country look like? How will that change?

Note that this is a different question than how SHOULD the mood look.

It is an interesting question into the public, national psyche how the war will be remembered.

FDR, Churchill ,Monty and the Auck

Funny thing about war...anyone can be opportunistic. Reputations are developed, enhanced, trashed, and rehabilitated for decades after the fact.

Of course, in this case I am referring to the early years of World War II when Germany was at or near their high water mark and the Allies were treading water, trying to stay afloat.

FDR was using the stick of withdrawing total American support to force Churchill to agree to New Deal principles for international exchanges.

Stalin was pushing Churchill to open a second front to take pressure off his beleaguered, apparently outmatched troops.

Parliament was pushing Churchill to prove Britain still had "the fighting spirit" after his disastrous moves in Greece and the Mediterranean.

And Auchinleck was trying to stem the irresistible force of Rommel's desert assault.

These were some of the key elements in deciding the fate of the world.

Now it is historians arguing over stuff like, "Was Auchinleck the right person at the right time? Would Brooke have let Churchill push Auchinleck out after Tobruk but before Al Amein if not for the visit by Hopkins?"

The funniest part of all of this to me is that Montgomery somehow came out of it looking outstanding. If ever there was the wrong General at the wrong place at the wrong time facing the wrong opponent...that would be Montgomery.

Not that Monty did not have his good points. After all, he did find success then and again later...even if his rate of movement lagged somewhat behind that of Clark, Patton, etc.

But that is just the point, isn't it? Patton and Rommel were two exemplary leaders in tank warfare. They understood that mobile firepower trumped static, easily out-flanked defensive lines. They understood that bold attacks with flexible elements could win great victories where superior numbers with more total firepower would see only defeat.

Monty missed all that. Yet somehow, he took the tactical innovations developed by Chink and implemented by Auchinlech and found a way to defeat an arguably vastly superior general.

True, Rommel had lost "the good source" of Bonner's briefs to Washington so no longer had the intelligence advantage, and also true he lacked the supplies he needed to fulfill the attack...yet attack he did.

It was precisely his unwillingness to force an attack that he believed would cost many of his men their lives to no possibility of victory that cost Auchinlech his post. Montgomery essentially fulfilled the plan for defense and training that the Auck had already laid down, and was rewarded with glory for his success.

Had the Auck been allowed to fight his campaign his way with his knowledge instead of men like Churchill trying to regain British prestige to fend off the political maneuverings of Roosevelt and Stalin, it is entirely possible he not only would have won Al Amein, but won bigger and more decisively, making the end of World War II more rapid with less loss of life.

Too bad politics got in the way. But don't they always?

A little matter of slaughter

Among the books I have read recently have been things that studied some interesting eras; the Greek world circa the 4th, 5th, and 6th centuries BC. The Greek and Roman worlds from the 4th century BC on up to the 5th century AD. The history of the Americas from the `5th century through the late 19th century. Looks at the World Wars, Korea, and Vietnam.



And there is a surprising theme that runs through all of them.



Carnage.



Massive, massive slaughter.



In the Peloponnesian War (fought between Athens and Greece, with a multitude of shifting alliances on each side) there were times when 30 or even 40% of the population of major Greek cities would die, whether from plague or sea-borne warfare.



Other times 95% or more of small or medium size citeis would be completely wiped out.



The Athenians killed the people of a city they had invested. The Spartans responded in kind. Then the Spartans asked for Helot volunteers who had fought for them previously...and promptly killed the 2000 who came forward.



Sea battles saw losses estimated as high as 40,000 people on a side. It has been suggested by some that the slaughter was greater than even the single-day butchers bill at Antietam, the battle toll from Gettysburg, etc.

Nor was that the only slaughter in the ancient world. Far from it. The Romans had their share, both by and against. Their losses at Teutoberg and Cannae spring readily to mind...as do the complete annihilation of Carthage.

Do we even need to look at the Middle Ages? The dark stains on Euro-history from the Crusades are awful.

The US history in warring against the Native Americans is hardly free from massacre. For that matter, our record in peacetime ain't none too good...and it is not just the Trail of Tears to which i refer.

Anyway, the point is that throughout history, there have been instance after instance after instance of indiscriminate slaughter. Massive numbers of slain, often for no particular reason other than being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

And for all the killing, for all the carnage, devastation, cruelty and mindless destruction, one fact becomes clear.

It never really seems to accomplish anything.

The Peloponnesian War lasted for generations, killing the best and brightest and rendering Greece impotent when the Romans began expanding.

The Romans killed by the thousands in Germany, Britain, and elsewhere. They were killed by the thousands in Italy, Germany, Britain, Persia...and they just kept going...for a while. Eventually the Germanic tribes overcame Rome.

I guess one could argue the horrific war crimes on the Washita and so forth accomplished something, though the murder there was not on quite so grand a scale.

The Russian murder of Poles, the German murder of Jews and "the other", these things accomplished nothing towards helping either win the war.

For that matter, the racial hatred shown in the pacific where the kill rates exceeded those of perhaps any war since the aforementioned Roman wars of annihilation did not win the war, either for the Japanese or for the Allies. It was not until nuclear bombs wiped out even more people and more indiscriminately that the war ended.

So if few wars have ever been won by the mass extermination of huge numbers of the foe (or their non-combatant dependents) has generally led not to peace but rather to more vociferous and effective opposition...why do people keep doing it?

This post will change the course of history

It is a common trope of historians to refer to certain events that "changed the course of history".

This trope comes forth with straight face and all seriousness, as if something of great import is being said, and that it is an indisputable fact that none can question.

There is a very real problem with it, however. It relies upon a fallacy.

Unfortunately for historians, history as they understand it has no predetermined path, no matter how much we wish it did.* All of history was not designed to produce Canada, for example. that the British wrested it from France, largely due to problems on the Continent, not in the New World, was not something predestined to happen.

In fact, with just a nudge here or there, things could have turned out differently. Spain could still rule the New World, England could be but a minor island and France could be part of the Prussian empire.

For that matter, with the advances in administration he made, G-diddy could have made it so we lived in a Mongolian vision of the world.

The point is, history is the study of what happened, not what the writer thinks should have happened. When Martin Luther nailed his 95 Theses to the door, he did not change the course of history. It was not an irrevocable path that the catholic church would rule for all time.

Nor was it necessarily going to happen that some priest would make the mistake of reading the Bible and actually try to apply that instead of the man-made traditions that had grown up around it.

That it happened is enough. It did not change history, nor change the course of history. It is simply an event which frankly bears more importance than some unknown peasant baking a loaf of bread on some random day.

Yes, some events are more important for the majority of the human race than others. Sometimes they are results not anticipated based on what came before. Sometimes they surprise people with the direction further events take.

But they did not change history. They simply became history.

By the way, this is one reason military history is so flawed. Some feel that the Romans might have won Adrianople had the Goth cavalry not surprised them with its unexpected return.

Irrelevant. The cavalry DID return. It did not change the course of history, it was the course history took.

So next time someone tells you about an event that changed the course of history, just ask them what course history was supposed to take.




* All of the above presupposes a view that, while God can guide events as He sees fit, the free choice He gave man allows events to proceed in ways meaningfully affected by those choices. This does not render God powerless but rather admits to His ability to guide events in the ways He sees fit, above and beyond our comprehension.

To Cross the Rubicon

The other day as I was driving I found myself behind a Jeep Rubicon. Later that day I heard a casual reference to someone saying they had "crossed the Rubicon." It got me to wondering how many people actually know the significance of that phrase, which is a reference to one of the more important and pivotal moments in history.

Rome developed as a Republic with unusually expansive voting rights. It was led by co-consuls who alternated days they were in power. The Senate was a powerful body indeed and with this system, the interests of the Plebeians (the poor, common folk) actually had occasional bouts of good will where the Patricians (the wealthy who controlled things) took care of some of their desires.

It was the Senate that decided whether or not military leaders would be granted a Triumph. Triumphs were parades to celebrate some notable military accomplishment and the glory for receiving one was the goal of virtually every General. 

However, it was just the general who received it. Armies were not allowed near Rome. To bring an army inside the barrier of the Rubicon was a violation of all the Roman Republic held dear and brought the weight of the entire Roman nation against the offender.

Only someone who was supremely confident (read "arrogant") would dare to bring an army across the river. Enter Julius Caesar. He had a long and interesting career that careened wildly from success to defeat. Working with and opposed by some of the greatest names in Roman history, he went from great military conquests to the consulship, back to the military and so forth.

To his credit, he did try to take care of his soldiers and to some extent of the poor of the land. But he had a rather self-centered outlook on things as well.

As an example, early in his career he was captured by pirates who, while he was in captivity, he promised to crucify. After his ransom he raised units sufficient to capture the pirates. His superior ordered him to sell them into slavery but he instead crucified them under his own authority...an egregious exceeding of his authority and rights that went unpunished.

Julius would grow used to exceeding his authority and getting away with it which is perhaps what led to the events of January 10, 49 B.C.

Returning from a consulship, he paused at the brink of the Rubicon. Already he had rebelled against the decree of the Senate in bringing the troops with him. However, he could easily overcome the consequences of this minor disobedience by turning back.

Instead, he crossed the Rubicon with his soldiers. There are different ways of saying what he said...Plutarch claims he said, "Let the die be thrown" but I prefer the more poetic Suetonius who claims he said, "The die is cast".

Either way, the truth is the future had changed direction. The crossing of the Rubicon was a fundamental shift in the outlook of the Roman nation. Shortly Caesar would win the Civil War when he defeated Pompey, the only real opposition. 

After this, the nature of Roman politics changed. At first it was Julius being voted "dictator" for a year a couple of times, then for a ten-year period (during which he was assassinated). 

Prior to this, Dictator was granted only in times of tremendous military distress and was only for the duration of the conflict. It was considered a duty rather than an honor and had none of the negative connotations we associate it with today. That began to change with Julius.

Setting aside the good and bad things he did, it is important to note that henceforth the Roman political system we are more familiar with of one King-like figure, generally called the Caesar, replaced the much more inclusive consuls and Senate system. And all because he crossed the Rubicon.

Thus we have a phrase that, at its smallest level, means to take a step that has serious consequences and cannot be turned back from, but at its greatest level can call to mind one of the pivotal moments in history.

Because it is MY team, that's why

How are politics like sports? I think I finally figured out the connection and it worries me. It is a sign of a huge flaw with democracy and republicanism (the political definition, not the party).

While I would not classify myself as a fanatic by any stretch of the imagination, I will admit I do enjoy a good deal of sports. I like to watch Monday Night Football if any of my myriad of teams I "like" is playing, will watch Thursday night or Saturday college ball if a game intrigues me, like to watch baseball and hockey during the playoffs, and basketball just about anytime.

One thing you quickly find out about sports is a lot of people have the WWI soldier's ideal; "Right or wrong, My country" only in this case it is "right or wrong, my team". Their players can do no wrong. If the opposing receiver goes out of bounds, takes three steps, and then gets blasted full speed they will complain about the penalty. If their favorite player picks off a rebound, goes the length of the floor on one dribble and dunks, they will complain if traveling is called. Conversely, if the opposition blasts their QB while he is looking down field they just know it was a late hit. And so forth.

In short, no matter how stupid, inane, or unreasonable the actions on the field or court, they will back their team because it is their team, not because they want to see the correct outcome.

Politics have become the same way. There are people who will back their party regardless of whether it is the right move or not. I must credit Mark Evanier for putting it in a form that crystallized what was bothering me.

Why on earth would anyone ever just punch the party ticket? Do they care that little about who represents them or the outcome?

This forthcoming election is a crucial one. We have two horrific choices; we can go with McCain who has become the new face of shifting positions and has not built any moral base to stand on or we can go with Obama who will do to health care what FDR did to welfare. Can this country withstand that level of stupidity and destruction?

But the problem lies not with this election but rather with the decades of people who have mindlessly punched the party ticket not because it was a wise choice or represented them but rather because, "I am a Destructocrat" or "I am a Republicant". What a stupid-*** reason to **** up this country and leave us a choice between the lesser of two evils.

Find any supporter of either Obama or McCain and ask them, "What are the top 10 issues where he is a good choice?" Not, "Why is he better than his opponent" but rather a positive, "My guy is good because".

It is easy to tear down. Putting noted plagiarist Joe Biden, a guy who said Obama was not a good choice, on his ticket is enough to disqualify Obama if you want to tear down, at least for me it is. You will never see me vote for someone who has demonstrated that level of moral turpitude.. Flipping multiple times on an issue such as abortion is enough to disqualify McCain. No need to look any further. If I wanted, I could find a dozen reasons to vote against either of them. But it is much harder to find a dozen reasons to vote FOR either of them.

So why do we not have legitimately good, across the board, POSITIVE choices? Because there are so many voters who throw away their votes by either "voting for the lesser of two evils" (while claiming someone voting FOR someone instead of AGAINST someone is the one "wasting" their vote) or by mindlessly punching the party ticket because "they are my team. Right or wrong, my party."

Voting that way has got us where we are today; a body of lawmakers with a higher percentage of scofflaws and financially inept people than any other institution in the country outside of prisons. *

So stop voting the party ticket. Use your brain when you go to the polls. Don't vote the lesser of two evils. Find someone worth voting for, no matter how "unelectable" someone is. Vote for good, not for evil. Because you might perceive of it as "voting for the lesser of two evils" but the message politicos hear is, "I am what they want".









* From an oft-passed e-mail that I have not bothered to vet, mostly because I suspect it understates the case:

36 have been accused of spousal abuse
7 have been arrested for fraud
19 have been accused of writing bad checks
117 have directly or indirectly bankrupted at least 2 businesses
3 have done time for assault
71,repeat 71 cannot get a credit card due to bad credit
14 have been arrested on drug-related charges
8 have been arrested for shoplifting
21 currently are defendants in lawsuits, and
84 have been arrested for drunk driving in the last year
Can you guess which organization this is?Give up yet? . .
The 435 Members of the Congress
********
If their math is correct, that is 380 of 435, over 87% who are certainly not worthy to be making laws.

Abraham Lincoln

When talking about the greatest Presidents of all time, President Abraham Lincoln is virtually always mentioned in the top 5...usually in the top 2 along with George Washington, perhaps the only 2 Presidents almost universally loved.



The reasons are obvious. Take this quote, for example:



Abraham Lincoln is commonly listed by historians as one of America's greatest presidents—often as the greatest of all. Part of the reason is that he provided strong leadership, set a clear course, and articulated a moral vision to guide the nation through very difficult times. Franklin Roosevelt, also recognized as one of America's best chief executives, once said that, "All our great presidents were leaders of thought at times when certain ideas in the life of the nation had to be clarified." And it was Lincoln's singular accomplishment that he clarified the goals of "union and freedom" for his time and for the ages, according to historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr.





Schlesinger is more or less a pretty respected historian and he is hardly committing career suicide with that assessment. You have to look quite a while before finding a reputable historian who does not agree. And I freely admit I think he was a pretty phenomenal President. Regardless of what his motivations for doing it were, the fact remains he ended slavery in the South (it was still legal in the States that did not secede). He did hold together an increasingly fractious Union and kept France and England from interceding on behalf of the South. But was he actually the leader we all have attributed him to be?



He had serious issues with his Commander in Chief Generals. When the war started he essentially fired Gen. Winfield Scott. There were some pretty solid reasons for this...Scott was well past his prime, was essentially immobile, and there was some internal dissension indicating unity under Scott might not be achieved. With that said...it WAS Scott who proposed a war strategy that, in the end, was the one used by Grant to split the South.



Gen. McClellan did not last long. Neither did Halleck. Or Meade. Or Hooker. Or McClellan again. Grant did last quite a while...but he was the 7th (SEVENTH) General Lincoln had in that post. In a war that lasted less than 5 years.

Furthermore, he had massive internal problems. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton usurped authority in ways that were pretty near treason. He also had the eternal struggle with Congress and public opinion. Harsh as it is to say this, after the successful (?) conclusion of the Civil War, Booth murdering him in some ways could be considered a mercy killing.

Lincoln presided over the bloodiest war in U.S. history. The Union dissolved and was unconstitutionally restored by force. He faced dissension and opposition from even those who were his closest supporters during the war over his rather generous terms for Reconstruction.

On the other hand, had he lived and been able to enforce his terms, it is very likely we would have never heard of Martin Luther King Jr. or Medgar Evers or Malcolm X...those questions quite possibly would have been settled and the country truly integrated under his leadership.

So that is a pretty strong counter argument to the things stated above.


Ultimately, there is a reason legend and myth grows around some people. Though I still despise the moral and financial harm FDR did to the country there is no denying the benefit he had on the SPIRIT of the people up to and during WWII. Lincoln may not have been as strong a guide as is sometimes presented...but he DID provide the glue to hold together the States, legal or not, and did push and sign the Emancipation Proclamation. So while there might be legitimate questions about individual aspects of his leadership and effectiveness...let the legend stand. He was a great leader and someone who should be looked up to. At least, that is my two cents...


What defines a hero?

World War II was a painful experience for virtually the entire world. On a personal level almost every person then alive felt the impact directly as a friend or relative, perhaps a neighbor, was someone who was injured or killed during the war. Yet even without the physical impact the emotional impact was terrifyingly high. It was an ideological war as one of its vital components.

You had the growing nationalism and racism of the Japanese (and if you have never examined this component I heartily endorse Race War in the Pacific, a hard to find but insightful tome into how the growth of pride in Asian power was a contributing factor to Japanese imperialism), Germans (if I need to explain this one you need to do a better job of studying even in the most cursory way the events surrounding WWII) as well as the growing racial awareness of others (the British came to understand the harmfulness of their domination of India, for example, the US marked a turning point as exploits of groups such as the Tuskegee airmen combined with shared experiences in the trenches to form the forces that would lead to the Civil Rights movements of the 50s and 60s).

You also had the violent clash of political and economic ideologies; the Imperialism of France, England, Germany, Japan, Russia and, to a lesser extent, the U.S. collided with each other alongside the clash of democracy with fascism with communism with Pan-Asianism.

There was heroism on all sides. It would be easy to dismiss, for example, the heroism of Germans as their deeds were swept under by the overarching evil of their pogroms and genocidal instincts. Yet it would not be accurate. Some Germans risked everything to help Jews. Some won medals for their combat heroics. Just because they were the enemy does not mean some of them did not perform heroic actions.

But now there is a war over memory. Take, for example, Estonia. For most of the Estonians the war brought forth oppression under the Soviets. It was a long period, lasting until 1991. And they do not wish to remember it as a positive thing. So they removed a war memorial...of a Soviet soldier.

To the Soviets this is very insulting. Millions upon millions of Soviets died to stop the Nazi menace. To the Soviets they were liberators. To the Estonians they were dominators, invaders, oppressors.

This is not unusual; not too long ago I read a book on the Punic Wars. At various times the same city-state would regard the Romans as liberators or oppressors, depending on how long they had been there. It pretty much has been that way ever since. Our own history is rife with times when "liberator" is a framing device for "conquest". And never forget...the "Battle" at Wounded Knee was among the most decorated "battles" ever recorded in American history. To the victims...err, losers, that has long been a sticking point. As recently as a year or so ago I was still seeing articles regarding the demand to have the Medals of honor rescinded. Why?

Because as long as those medals are out there as awards then the nation officially recognizes a tragic massacre as a heroic action. It is a symbol of wrong being treated as a heroic action.

As such, I completely understand where the Estonians are coming from. The Soviet regime was many things...murderous, vengeful, oppressive...and having a tribute to a representative would be difficult to bear.

By the same token...for the Soviets, the price they paid was indeed huge. Of course, a lot of this was because of the nature of their armies; poorly trained, under-equipped, horribly led, and motivated by fear....they threw away millions of men because the men meant nothing to them. They would abandon entire armies and simply order them to fight to the death...or return to be tortured to death. And these armies were to achieve no strategic purpose.

In other words, the cost in men was much higher than it needed to be. Regardless, the numbers were staggering...and it is certainly understandable how they might believe that sacrifice gives them certain rights or honors due them.

If I were Estonian I would certainly want the statue torn down. If I were Russian I would want it up. There is no easy answer.

The Story
The Analysis

The addendum; for those who want a required bi-lingual forum and are against the "English as official language" crowd and did not learn from the dissension rippling across Canada...check out how the language is affecting the above situation as those who do not speak the dominant language feel "discriminated against". Hmm.